I was very dissapointed with my experience with dr. rose. I did not feel the doctor listened to my concerns. he seemed very preoccupied and did not try to resolve my problems. he kept trying to convince me to do surgery and he kept confusing which side had knee pain. It turns out he is trained in hand surgery. I went to another doctor in the area and he prescribed physical therapy and my knee is much better. i am so happy i did not have surgery. I do not recommend dr. rose.